Odd Muse: Power of Authenticity, Product-First Strategy & Community Engagement

In the hyper-competitive world of DTC fashion, Odd Muse has achieved a rare kind of growth, marked by founder-led storytelling, product-driven focus, and a community-centered approach to social media. 

Founded by Aimee Smale at age 21, Odd Muse began with one iconic piece—the blazer—and grew into a brand that embodies “investment fashion” with pieces designed to last. Through authenticity, deliberate product curation, and savvy community engagement, Odd Muse has developed a loyal following and a distinct position in the fashion industry. 

This case study delves into three pillars of Odd Muse’s success: founder-led authenticity, product-first strategy, and community engagement.

1. Founder-Led Authenticity

One of Odd Muse’s most defining attributes is its founder-led authenticity.Aimee Smale, the face and driving force of the brand, left a stable role at Asos to launch Odd Muse with only £12,000 in savings. 

Aimee used Instagram and TikTok not just as platforms to promote Odd Muse but as channels to document her journey, challenges, and triumphs. This personal narrative made the brand accessible and relatable in a way few DTC brands achieve.

Amiee's approach to sharing her story, from the initial struggles to viral successes, built a strong sense of trust and connection with her audience. She often posts content that gives followers a behind-the-scenes view into her creative process, product development, and even mishaps, like a near-miss in Dubai that cost her £55,000.

These unfiltered updates have given Odd Muse a personality and a transparency that resonates deeply with customers, setting it apart in an industry where authenticity is often overshadowed by polished brand images. 

In a landscape where fashion brands can seem impersonal, Odd Muse’s authenticity and Aimee’s transparency have made it one of the few DTC brands where the founder’s story is inseparable from the brand.

‍

2. Product-First Strategy

Odd Muse’s approach to product design and curation is rooted in creating “investment pieces.” Rather than attempting to compete in the fast-fashion space with high volume and low price points, Odd Muse’s strategy centers on developing quality products that are versatile and timeless. 

The brand’s first hero product, the blazer, exemplified this ethos. Aimee knew that if she focused on making one exceptional product, it could become a signature piece that customers would return to. The blazer quickly became a hit, driving massive early growth and proving that a product-first strategy could pay off. 

By resisting the urge to introduce too many products at once, Odd Muse avoided the typical fashion cycle of rapid, disposable trends. Instead, the brand carefully expanded with items that align with its identity, such as the Pearl Dress, a standout success that grossed over £1 million in just one quarter.

This focus on one or two hero products at a time, rather than flooding the market, allowed Odd Muse to establish itself as a reliable source of quality, investment-worthy fashion. In doing so, Odd Muse distinguished itself from fast-fashion competitors and built a customer base that values longevity and style over fleeting trends.

‍

3. Community Engagement through Social Media

Community engagement has been pivotal to Odd Muse’s success. Early on, Aimee recognized the potential of platforms like TikTok and Instagram to drive organic growth and leveraged them in distinct ways. TikTok became Odd Muse’s platform for brand discovery, using viral moments to attract new customers, while Instagram was used to foster deeper brand loyalty and community connection.

A prime example of this was when a TikTok influencer posted about Odd Muse’s blazer, triggering a surge in orders. However, Aimee knew that while TikTok could drive traffic and quick sales, it wasn’t sustainable for consistent revenue. She pivoted to using Instagram as a foundation for brand loyalty, sharing behind-the-scenes looks, product development updates, and styling tips.

Aimee’s founder-led storytelling and willingness to show “the real story” resonated with followers, encouraging them to become loyal customers rather than one-time buyers.

Odd Muse also capitalized on customer content, regularly resharing posts from customers styling their Odd Muse pieces. This engagement with real customers not only amplified word-of-mouth marketing but also created a genuine sense of community. 

By encouraging user-generated content and directly engaging with followers, Aimee turned customers into brand ambassadors who actively participate in Odd Muse’s growth story. The brand’s community-oriented strategy on Instagram has fostered a feedback loop, with customers feeling recognized and appreciated while contributing to Odd Muse’s online credibility and reach.

‍

Lessons from Odd Muse’s Success

Odd Muse’s journey illustrates how a DTC brand can achieve sustainable growth through authenticity, product quality, and community engagement. Aimee Smale’s transparency and hands-on involvement give the brand a distinct voice and trust factor, her focus on a small selection of well-designed products has set Odd Muse apart, and her social media strategy has created a loyal, engaged customer base. 

These three pillars have established Odd Muse as more than just a fashion brand; it is a community-driven, founder-led story of creativity, resilience, and quality. For DTC brands navigating today’s landscape, Odd Muse serves as a compelling example of how founder authenticity, a product-first mindset, and community engagement can drive sustainable, long-term success.

‍